Toronto Restaurants
Background image brought to you by La Vecchia Ristorante
2405A Yonge St.
Loading Location
Reserve online at your favourite restaurants in Toronto and across the GTA. Our real-time reservation system allows you to book available tables instantly from the restaurant's electronic reservation book.
Enjoying a meal at La Scala is a culinary journey, their award winning chefs use fresh ingredients and cook all items as per order to enhance the taste of all meals. La Scala is open six days a week and can be booked for private functions and catering needs ~ at their place or your place. La Scala is able to close the restaurant for private functions of 40 people or more.
Take a Tour
La Scala Ristorante The Menu
The Menu

Review: Homemade Italian in a fine setting

By Stephanie Dickison, reviewed on December 15, 2008

Miriam Cosalini loves people. It's clearly what she is meant to do-talk with people and make them feel good.

Miriam owns La Scala Ristorante along with her restaurateur husband, Hector, and for the last four years, they have been serving a loyal clientele...

Miriam Cosalini loves people. It's clearly what she is meant to do-talk with people and make them feel good.

Miriam owns La Scala Ristorante along with her restaurateur husband, Hector, and for the last four years, they have been serving a loyal clientele that seem more like extended family members than customers.

"Customers are like my guests. We give them the very best," Miriam says.
The intimate restaurant is open for both lunch and dinner, but it's here at the dinner house that you have the luxury of settling back into the quiet ambiance and attentive care that is as integral to La Scala as the food.

Like entering a friend's formal dining room, the restaurant has a warm, familiar touch. Spacious seating under chandeliers emitting a soft glow suits a romantic dinner or a special occasion. Carpeting and multi-level seating allow for an intimate experience while the comfortable ivory-coloured chairs imply that you will end up staying awhile.

The dishes are prepared simply, but in such a way that it surpasses anything you could do at home. Chef Nino (Carmine O'Otolo) has created a "mix of old traditional Italian with Mediterranean" dishes. The small menu has additional weekly specials, ensuring that there is something for everyone.

Everything is made in house and from scratch, including the bread which changes daily. Today's offering is a warm wheat and honey bread that is dense with a flour-dusted crust. It's because of homemade bread like this I understand why there are so many crazy bread lovers in the world.

The Caprese Salad ($9) -vine tomatoes, fiore di latte mozzarella and fresh basil drizzled with rich, extra virgin olive oil-is superb in its freshness and simplicity. Polpo alla Griglia ($11) features fire-grilled octopus atop a bed of mixed greens with extra virgin olive oil and lemon juice. The octopus is meaty with charred tentacles and is delightfully chewy without being rubbery.

The Tagliolini Mediterraneo ($22) highlights the fresh, in-house made pasta alongside tiger shrimp, sea scallops, capers, black olives, green onions and white wine all in a light tomato sauce. The combination of sweet seafood with the saltiness of the capers and olives provides a nice balance. It is a fresh, light dish that is wholly satisfying.

But it's the Vitella con Porcini ($23) that has captivated me. Milk-fed veal scallopini, imported porcini mushrooms, white wine and veal jus swirl together to create a creamy mouth-watering sensation.

Of course, the porcini mushrooms come with their own story. Miriam doesn't like dried mushrooms; she says the flavour is never nearly as robust as when they are fresh. Porcinis are also incredibly difficult to get. But because Chef Nino worked in Montreal, he has found someone who can import them from Italy in order to supply the restaurant. Their flavour is rich and earthy and just slightly nutty. It adds depth to the soft veal and complements the creamy new potatoes, crisp broccoli, sweet red pepper, carrots and zucchini.

For dessert, a large piece of homemade Tiramisu ($7) arrives and I ashamed to say that I polished off three-quarters of this monster slice. I couldn't help myself-the cold, creamy texture is so light and despite being heavily dusted in chocolate, is not overly sweet. Paired with an expertly made cappuccino, it's an indulgent, yet perfect, cap to the meal.

In the end, it's rare that I walk into a place for the first time and feel such a longing to come back. But don't be surprised if it happens to you, too, after you finish your first meal at La Scala Ristorante.

Reviews are meant to describe a dining out experience at a given period in time and are the personal opinion of the writer.
All meals are paid for, including all taxes and gratuities. All reservations are made under assumed names. Menu items, prices and individuals mentioned in this review may not be up to date. Dine.TO encourages its users to share their feedback.

Latest Comments

New User's Image
Would you recommend?
No comments posted yet
 Please select only one reason why you would recommend this business.